What if while Grindlewald was posing as Graves he managed to court, woo and seduce Newt. Newt falls completely in love with the wizard he thinks is Graves. Grindle!Graves revels in this and acts every part the besotted wizard, even leading Newt on to think he'll propose to Newt.
When something tips Newt off and he reveals Grindlewald's deception, he's horrified that he's been duped, that he allowed a dark wizard into his heart and bed, allowed *Grindlewald* to take his virginity, even wanted to marry. Of course it wasn't really Graves and he didn't know it was Grindlewald, but he feels dirty and heart broken.
The real Graves is found mostly unharmed, and things slowly go back to normal, Newt stays to help MACUSA, but Newt is still in love with 'Graves' even though he knows it wasn't real, all the memories and feelings won't go, and despite Newt trying to hide it, Graves is very aware of this.
What happens is up to anon. Happy ending for Newt/Graves desired.
Grindle!Graves/Newt (dub-con), Graves/Newt Newt fell for Grindle!Graves before truth revealed
When something tips Newt off and he reveals Grindlewald's deception, he's horrified that he's been duped, that he allowed a dark wizard into his heart and bed, allowed *Grindlewald* to take his virginity, even wanted to marry. Of course it wasn't really Graves and he didn't know it was Grindlewald, but he feels dirty and heart broken.
The real Graves is found mostly unharmed, and things slowly go back to normal, Newt stays to help MACUSA, but Newt is still in love with 'Graves' even though he knows it wasn't real, all the memories and feelings won't go, and despite Newt trying to hide it, Graves is very aware of this.
What happens is up to anon. Happy ending for Newt/Graves desired.