Instead of Jacob having the idential suitcase and accidentally switching with Newt, some one else does. Preferrably a canon (one of the Shaws? Mary Lou? GrindelGraves?!?) but anyone else who could concievably been in NY with a tan/brown suitcase like the Man In the Tan Jacket, with a Briefcase Full of Flies, from Night Vale is also cool.
AU If Newt's suitcase had been switched with someone else's
like the Man In the Tan Jacket, with a Briefcase Full of Flies, from Night Valeis also cool.