So Newt and Graves are in a relationship, maybe new maybe established, when Theseus stops by New York to visit. One thing leads to another and Graves ends up sleeping with Theseus and Newt finds out. Whatever happens next is up to the author!

+Bonus points for Graves and Theseus having oh shit what did we do and being honestly upset by what they did.
++Newt struggles with confronting Graves and his brother and begins to question his self worth.
+++Graves comes home and all of Newt's things are just gone.