fantasticbeasts_kinkmeme | Prompt Post #2

ROUND 2

Seeing as we've reached 4,000 comments in Round 1, it's time to make a new one. Same (lack of) rules apply. Gentle reminder to everyone to refrain from posting extremely long prompts, though. While no word limit will be imposed, take note that it is very unlikely for someone to fulfill your prompt if your prompt alone is already several paragraphs long and containing a number of specifications.

ANNOUNCEMENTS:
-(01/14/2016) We now have a TRADING POST where you can exchange fills with people.
-The prompt freeze is over! You may resume posting prompts. The next freeze is scheduled on February 8, 12:00 AM (PST) or if this round reaches 4,000 comments; whichever comes first.
-Due to popular demand, we now have our first couple of rules!
RULE #1: No prompt must exceed 250 words. Any prompt that exceeds that WILL be screened.
RULE #2: Please state RPF in the subject line if your prompt involves real people.
RULE #3: No kinkshaming.

Also: interested in helping out the kink meme? We are in need of:
-Mods to help manage the kinkmeme itself
-Volunteers to help update the tumblr page
If you have free time to do one or the other, go ahead and e-mail us at fantasticbeastskink@gmail.com.
Thank you to those who have already volunteered, and have a nice day.

Important links:
You can check for fill updates at our tumblr page
You can upload your stories on AO3 anonymously here or non-anymously here.
You can alert us that you've filled a prompt here
You can talk about anything here

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

When Newt receives a call telling him his twin brother Theodore is dead, Newt is devastated. He and Theseus haven’t spoken for three years and haven’t seen each other for four, but Theseus is...was still his twin, his best friend.

For the last three years, Newt has been desperately trying to put his life back together after it spiralled out of control after a deep betrayal, and he’s struggling to build some semblance of a life. Newt makes his way to his brother’s home where he meets the one person he’s been dreading, Percival Graves. Theseus’s husband, and now grieving widower.

Newt has loved Percival for as long as he can remember but knew Percival never felt anything for him. Despite being identical everyone always wanted Theseus, loved him and Newt understood. He was the screw-up, the failure in the family, the one who was a walking disater. Theseus was the golden boy, everyone knew that, reminded Newt of it constantly, it’s just how it worked.

But Newt discovers not everything is how it seems. Percival doesn’t seem heartbroken by his husband’s death, in fact he seems relieved and almost...happy, which shocks Newt, not to mention Percival tries to spend as much time as possible with Newt, which for Newt is both torture and heaven, because Percival is still the kindest, more amazing person he’s ever known and he feels terrible for being in love with his twin’s husband but he knows Percival world never even look at him like that, and wonders how much he sees Theseus when he looks at Newt. People have spent Newt’s whole life doing that.

Newt is finding it hard to deal with being out from his twin’s shadow, but Percival seems determined to help and as Newt discovers everything about his brother life was a lie, nothing but smoke and mirrors, including his marriage. Theseus’s life was way more screwed up than Newt’s.

And then there’s another bombshell. Theseus isn’t exactly…dead.

Prompt Post #2

Graves/Newt, Newt's perfect twin